1958 Dockerty Cup Results

written by John Punshon
Sources: Sources: The Age, Soccer News, The Sporting Globe, The Sun, Sunshine Advocate, VASFA Year Book 1959

Home Team v Away Team
Round One
Saturday, May 24, 1958
Dandenong Rovers

Walkover to Dandenong Rovers
- Corio

Walkover to Dandenong Rovers
Saturday, May 24, 1958. ICI Ground, Deer Park.
Imperial Chemical Industries

Goal: Thomlinson
1 - 5 Fiorentina
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Yarra Park, Melbourne.
Lions
Line-up not known
3 - 0 Frankston
Albers, C Zylstra, J Wren, W Bouwmeester, P De Jonge, Rossetto, B Sampson, V Heath, H Gussenhoven, Lymer, Betts, A McLean. [Soccer News]
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Princes Park, Carlton North.
Maccabi
2 - 1 Sandringham City
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Elwood Reserve, Elwood.
Melbourne
4 - 0 Melbourne University
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Venue not known.
Newborough United
2 - 2 Bendigo
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Middle Park.
Park Rangers
Godbold, Willee, Moat, Stephenson, Collett, K West, Holder, R West, Moran, Mulcahy, McKenzie, Lazenby. [Soccer News]
1 - 2 Prahran City
Line-up included: Jater, Drake & Freeman.
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Middle Park.
South Melbourne United
Del Mannering, Eric Hayes, Ray Eagleton, Bill Annesley, Alan Thompson, Billy Guy, Bob Cottrill, Peter, Don Jordon, Colin Macleod, Graeme James. [Soccer News]
Note: Jack Wilson was a late inclusion in the team.
Goals: Wilson x 2, Other scorers not known
5 - 1 Richmond Alemannia
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Venue not known.
Victorian Colts
2 - 1 Heidelberg
Saturday, May 24, 1958. JT Gray Reserve, North Williamstown.
Williamstown
4 - 0 Fairfield
Saturday, May 24, 1958. Yarra Park, Melbourne.
Yarra Park
3 - 0 St Albans
Byes: Twenty-one teams
Round One Replay
Saturday, June 7, 1958. Venue not known.
Bendigo
2 - 4 Newborough
Round Two
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Victoria Street, Bayswater.
Bayswater
4 - 2 Newborough United
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Royal Park, Parkville.
Brunswick
1 - 4 Hayduk
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Cole Reserve, Pascoe Vale.
Coburg United

Goals: J McKee pen, Other scorer not known
2 - 1 Croatia
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Whitehall Street, Yarraville.
Commonwealth Fertilisers
3 - 4 Seymour
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Brennock Park, Ferntree Gully.
Ferntree Gully
2 - 3 Victorian Colts
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Flinders Naval Depot, Crib Point.
Flinders Naval Depot
2 - 6 South Yarra
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Yarra Park, Melbourne..
Lions
2 - 2 Prahran City
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Princes Park, Carlton North.
Maccabi
Line-up not known
0 - 5 Sunshine City
N Boudrie, McCall, J Reid, Jack Henderson, Gstrein, F Nithsdale, Brady, J Grant, Jeffrey, Kyle, Hazler, J Borg. [Selected team, Sunshine Advocate]
Goals: Brady x 3, Jeffrey x 2
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Patterson Road, Moorabbin.
Moorabbin City
6 - 2 Dandenong Rovers
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Main Ridge.
Rosebud
2 - 4 Olympia
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Venue not known.
Sicilia
2 - 2 Fiorentina
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Middle Park.
South Melbourne United
12 - 0 Croydon
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Sunshine Park, Sunshine.
Sunshine United

Goal: K Hitchings
1 - 5 Preston Technical School Old Boys
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Yarra Park, Melbourne.
Victoria Police
2 - 2 Yallourn
Saturday, June 21, 1958. JT Gray Reserve, North Williamstown.
Williamstown
2 - 3 Footscray Capri
Saturday, June 21, 1958. Yarra Park, Melbourne.
Yarra Park
0 - 1 Melbourne
Round Two Replays
Saturday, July 5, 1958. Yarra Bend National Park, Kew.
Fiorentina
2 - 1 Sicilia
Saturday, July 5, 1958. Como Park, South Yarra.
Prahran
2 - 5 Lions
Saturday, July 5, 1958. Yallourn Recreation Reserve, Yallourn.
Yallourn
7 - 0 Victoria Police
Round Three
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Cole Reserve, Pascoe Vale.
Coburg United
2 - 1 Moorabbin City
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Yarra Bend National Park, Kew.
Fiorentina
1 - 0 South Melbourne United
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Henry Turner Reserve, Footscray.
Footscray Capri
2 - 0 Preston Technical School Old Boys
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Royal Park, Parkville.
Hayduk
2 - 7 Bayswater
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Yarra Park, Melbourne.
Lions
3 - 1 Melbourne
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Sassella Park, Deer Park.
Olympia
Line-up not known
0 - 2 Sunshine City
N Boudrie, McCall, J Reid, J Grant, Gstrein, F Nithsdale, Brady, Jackson, Jeffrey, Kyle, Hazler, Hope. [Selected team, Sunshine Advocate]
Goals: F Nithsdale,Other scorer not known
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Fawkner Park, South Yarra.
South Yarra
1 - 0 Seymour
Saturday, July 12, 1958. Venue not known.
Victorian Colts
3 - 1 Yallourn
Round Four
Saturday, August 2, 1958. Victoria Street, Bayswater.
Bayswater
Blaich, Seegets, Jim Ashton, Klaus Imberger, E Fuchs, A Fuchs, Kaeser, Steller, Weller, Steller, Phil Guy. Res: Beilharz, Wied. [Soccer News]
5 - 1 Lions
Line-up not known.
Saturday, August 2, 1958. Yarra Bend National Park, Kew.
Fiorentina

After extra time
1 - 4 Victorian Colts

After extra time
Saturday, August 2, 1958. Fawkner Park, South Yarra.
South Yarra
Woodward, Paris, Tan, Jakopovis, Pemberton, McKenzie, Hofstepe, Tilley, Nicholls, Lott, Murphy. Res: Westley, Reitbauer, Karamilidis, Churchill. [Soccer News]
0 - 6 Footscray Capri
Saturday, August 2, 1958. Sunshine Park, Sunshine.
Sunshine City
N Boudrie, McCall, J Reid, Jack Henderson, Gstrein, F Nithsdale, Brady, J Grant, Jeffrey, Kyle, Hazler, Jackson. [Selected team, Sunshine Advocate]
Goals: Brady, Hazler, Jeffrey
3 - 2 Coburg United
G Carmichael, G King, S Galea, Bill Clements, L Day, A Clements, F Farrugia, J McKee, J Gilliland, J Smith, T Galea. Res: B Mercer, E Sacco. [Soccer News]
Goals: Gilliland, Other scorer not known
Round Five
(State League teams enter)
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Henry Turner Reserve, Footscray.
Footscray Capri
3 - 1 Box Hill
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Campbell Reserve, Coburg.
George Cross
Line-up not known.
6 - 0 Bayswater
Blaich, Seegets, Clauss, Klaus Imberger, E Fuchs, A Fuchs, Phil Guy, Weller, Steller, Steller, Kaeser, Jim Ashton, Beilharz. [Soccer News]
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Murphy Reserve, Port Melbourne.
Hellenic
1 - 0 Moreland
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Como Park, South Yarra.
JUST
2 - 2 Slavia-Port Melbourne
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Maribyrnong Reserve, Maribyrnong.
Polonia
4 - 1 Brighton
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Sunshine Park, Sunshine.
Sunshine City
Simpson, Gstrein, J Reid, Jack Henderson, Sexton, F Nithsdale, Brady, Jackson, Jeffrey, Kyle, Hazler, J Borg. [Selected team, Sunshine Advocate]
Goals: Hazler x 3
3 - 2 Geelong
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Elsternwick Park, Elwood.
Victorian Colts
1 - 4 Juventus
Saturday, August 16, 1958. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: Bill Curran.
Wilhelmina
Line-up included: Cor Morks, Cor Mathyssen, Arie Luyten, Rein Yntema, Tjibbe Keuken & Mike de Bruyckere..
Goals: Yntema, Keuken, DeBruyckere
3 - 2 Hakoah
Line-up included: Hans Van Egmond, Bill Harburn, Terry Hartley, Ferenc Bors, Walter Ardner & Ralph Piercy..
Goals: Bors, Ardner
Round Five Replay
Saturday, August 23, 1958. Murphy Reserve, Port Melbourne.
Slavia-Port Melbourne
2 - 1 JUST
Quarter-Finals
Saturday, September 6, 1958. Campbell Reserve, Coburg.
George Cross
2 - 1 Hellenic
Saturday, September 6, 1958. Maribyrnong Reserve, Maribyrnong.
Polonia
1 - 2 Juventus
Saturday, September 6, 1958. Olympic Park, Melbourne.
Slavia-Port Melbourne
Line-up included: Alec Glennie & Bill Cook.
Goals: Glennie, Cook, Other scorer not known
After extra time
3 - 2 Footscray Capri
Line-up included: Massesse, Pelosa, Capolicchio, Grego & Ureyeo.
Goals: Capolicchio, Ureyeo
After extra time
Saturday, September 6, 1958. Sunshine Park, Sunshine.
Sunshine City
Simpson, J Reid, Gstrein, Jack Henderson, Sexton, F Nithsdale, Brady, Jackson, Moore, Kyle, Hazler, J Grant, J Borg. [Selected team, Sunshine Advocate]
Goal: Sexton
1 - 2 Wilhelmina
Line-up included: Cor Mathyssen & Mike De Bruyckere.
Goals: Mathyssen pen, De Bruyckere
Semi-Finals
Saturday, September 20, 1958. Olympic Park, Melbourne.
George Cross
Line-up not known.
0 - 4 Juventus
Line-up included: Igor Scalamera, Ermes Boz & Joe Plateo.
Goals: Scalamera x 2, Boz, Plateo
Saturday, September 27, 1958. Olympic Park, Melbourne.
Slavia-Port Melbourne

Goals: Cook
1 - 5 Wilhelmina

Goals: Luyten x 2, Petersen, Keuken, De Bruyckere
1958 Dockerty Cup Final
Saturday, October 11, 1958. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: Bill Curran.
Juventus
Line-up included: Nerino Vitti, John Picinich, Saico, Angelo Marini, Frangionim Bressan, Pepe Cubero, Enzo Bottari & Frank Barbazza.
Goals: Bottari x 2
After extra time
2 - 2 Wilhelmina
Line-up included: Cor Morks, Cor Mathyssen, Bill Westerveld, Sloothaak, Tony Noy, Hans Petersen & Mike De Bruyckere.
Goals: Mathyssen pen, De Bruyckere
After extra time
1958 Dockerty Cup Final Replay
Saturday, October 18, 1958. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Att: 10,000. Referee: Bill Curran.
Juventus
Line-up included: Nerino Viti, Bressan (sent off 75) & Enzo Bottari (sent off 88).
0 - 3 Wilhelmina
Line-up included: Rein Yntema, Tjibbe Keuken, Mike De Bruyckere (sent off 88), Arie Luyten & Hans Petersen.
Goals: Yntema 12, Keuken 47, Scorer not known 83